Site Audits & Conversion Rate Optimization

9908909090 2

In today's digital landscape, having an effective website is no longer optional for businesses - it's imperative. But simply having a website isn't enough. You need to optimize it for maximum performance, engagement, and conversions. This is where conversion rate optimization (CRO) audits come in.

A CRO audit is a systematic evaluation of your website to identify and address any barriers standing in the way of conversions. By leveraging data, testing, and optimization best practices, you can transform your website into a high-converting powerhouse.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore what CRO audits entail, why they're critical, and provide an actionable 10-step framework for conducting your own audits to unlock the full potential of your website.

What Exactly is a Conversion Rate Optimization Audit?

A CRO audit examines your website through a conversion-focused lens to find and fix issues negatively impacting your ability to acquire, engage, and convert visitors. It entails thoroughly analyzing both qualitative and quantitative data to diagnose problems and identify opportunities to optimize user experience and boost conversions.

The key elements of a CRO audit include:

  • Setting conversion goals: Determine your desired actions - do you want more newsletter signups, free trial starts, purchases? Align your goals with business objectives.

  • Analyzing site analytics: Identify underperforming pages, high exit rates, trends, etc. that indicate issues. Tools like Google Analytics are invaluable.

  • Assessing user experience: Pinpoint UX pain points through methods like user surveys, tests, heatmaps. Check for issues like confusing navigation, poor page layouts, broken forms.

  • Finding technical issues: Audit site speed, mobile optimization, tracking implementation, data collection. Technical problems seriously hurt conversions.

  • Prioritizing opportunities: Focus on quick wins first. Consider potential impact, ease of implementation and cost.

  • Testing solutions: Use A/B and multivariate testing to validate and optimize solutions. Continuously improve through controlled experiments.

  • Tracking performance: Monitor key metrics to analyze CRO efforts' impact and fine-tune strategies. Optimization is an ongoing process.

Essentially, a CRO audit helps you diagnose conversion "diseases" through examination and data analysis, so you can prescribe targeted "treatments" in the form of prioritized optimizations. It's a research-driven approach allowing you to enhance CX and boost conversions in a sustainable, results-driven manner.

Why Conversion Rate Optimization Matters

With more business conducted online, your website's ability to convert visitors into customers is a make-or-break factor for success. Consider these conversion optimization stats:

  • On average, only 2-3% of website visitors convert. There's massive room for improvement.

  • Improving conversion rates by just 1% can increase annual revenue by millions for larger companies.

  • 71% of marketers say improving conversion rates gives them the best ROI.

  • Websites with above-average conversion rates bring in 88% more revenue per visitor.

Clearly, boosting your conversion rates through CRO has tremendous upside for your business. But trying to improve conversions without data and optimization best practices typically yields disappointing results.

The key is taking a structured approach through conversion rate optimization audits. This allows you to allocate time, money and development efforts toward fixes that will actually move the needle for your business.

The Cost of Ignoring CRO Audits

Neglecting CRO audits can come at a high cost in terms of lost conversions, wasted resources and frustrated customers. Without understanding user behavior and diagnosing site issues, you are essentially flying blind in optimization efforts. Symptoms of inadequate CRO practices include:

  • Plummeting conversion rates over time as problems go undetected.

  • Pouring money into ineffective optimizations yielding no results.

  • Declining customer satisfaction from a subpar user experience.

  • Losing customers to competitors offering a superior experience.

  • Wasting development time building features users don't need.

  • Failure to capitalize on quick gains leaving money on the table.

Conducting CRO audits eliminates these pitfalls by bringing data, strategic insights and best practices into the optimization process. You get the direction and validation needed to optimize effectively.

How Much Can Conversion Rates Improve with CRO?

The uplift in conversion rates you can achieve through CRO varies based on your business and website specifics. However, improvements typically fall in the 20-100% range. For example:

  • An audit helped non-profit client Mercy Corps double donation page conversion rates in 6 months.

  • Design firm Brucira saw a 21% increase in contact form conversion rates through their CRO program.

  • Global consulting firm McKinsey optimized service line landing pages, improving conversions by over 40%.

  • Software company AppSumo performed ongoing CRO to increase trial starts 100% year-over-year.

These examples demonstrate the tremendous impact CRO audits can have when done right. The data and insights uncovered in the audits allowed these companies to achieve dramatic, sustainable improvements by addressing conversion barriers.

10 Steps to Execute a Conversion Rate Optimization Audit

Now that we've covered the importance of CRO, let's explore a step-by-step framework for executing conversion rate optimization audits. Follow these 10 key steps:

1. Establish Key Performance Indicators

First, determine the key performance indicators (KPIs) you will measure to assess conversion performance. KPIs also serve to align teams by providing a shared definition of success.

Common CRO KPIs include:

  • Bounce rate (% exiting without another page view)
  • Pages/session
  • Average time on page
  • Conversion rate
  • Average order value

Select 3-5 KPIs directly tied to your goals. For example, an ecommerce site could track revenue per session, average order value and bounce rate on product pages.

2. Set Conversion Goals

With your KPIs established, set specific, measurable conversion goals. The goals should connect to broader business objectives. Examples:

  • Increase free trial signups by 15% in 6 months
  • Reduce shopping cart abandonment by 8% in 1 quarter
  • Grow monthly newsletter subscribers by 25% year-over-year

Defining clear conversion goals gives your audit focus and frames optimization hypotheses. Share goals with stakeholders to align efforts.

3. Review Site Analytics

Your website analytics platform is a goldmine of insights for guiding optimization efforts. Thoroughly review your metrics to spot trends, anomalies and underperforming pages.

Key questions to investigate:

  • Which acquisition sources drive the most conversions?
  • Do mobile/desktop conversion rates significantly differ?
  • When do dropoffs occur in the conversion funnel?
  • What pages have the highest exit rates?
  • Are conversions rising or falling over time?

Look for patterns tied to seasons, campaigns, releases, etc. that may influence performance. Diagnose core issues to address in the audit.

4. Analyze Site Speed and Technical Factors

Technical issues on your site can cripple conversions, no matter how great your offer is. Rigorously assess:

  • Site speed: Page load times under 2 seconds are ideal. Review SpeedCurve or PageSpeed Insights.

  • Mobile optimization: Test mobile experience on all devices. Google's Mobile-Friendly Test checks performance.

  • Site uptime: Track any downtime causing lost conversions. 99%+ uptime should be the goal.

  • Tracking implementation: Is analytics data collection set up properly? Audit tags for accuracy.

Identify technical problems contributing to conversion issues observed in analytics, like high bounce rates.

5. Conduct Competitive Analysis

Review how top competitors' website designs, content and features influence their conversion performance. Compare:

  • Page layouts
  • Calls-to-action
  • Content presentation
  • Feature conversion funnels

This can reveal creative optimization approaches and opportunities to experiment on your site.

6. Interview Stakeholders

Meet with sales, support, product teams, executives, etc. to gather qualitative insights. Ask:

  • What are customers' biggest problems or motivations?
  • Where do staff see conversion challenges?
  • What new opportunities exist to improve conversion performance?

This helps spot issues analytics alone can't reveal and aligns stakeholders to audit findings.

7. Survey Users

User surveys provide direct input on frustrations and needs that may block conversions. Key questions to ask:

  • How easy was it to find what you needed?
  • What worked well or felt confusing?
  • How likely are you to recommend our site?

Phone or live chat surveys allow probing questions. Online surveys work for broader feedback. Offer incentives for quality responses.

8. Conduct User Tests

Observing actual user behavior reveals conversion friction points. Methods include:

  • Moderated tests: Watch users complete tasks and think aloud about site experience.

  • Unmoderated tests: Have users complete tasks on a test site while recording their interactions.

  • Heatmaps: Visualize click patterns to see how users navigate and engage.

Address usability pain points uncovered, like confusing navigation or forms.

9. Prioritize Opportunities

Compile audit findings into a conversion rate optimization roadmap. Prioritize opportunities using a 2x2 matrix assessing effort vs. impact:

[Insert image of 2x2 prioritization matrix]

Focus initial efforts on quick wins with high impact and low effort. Longer-term initiatives can follow.

10. Test and Iterate

Use A/B and multivariate testing to validate and optimize solutions identified in the audit. Common tests include:

  • Page layout changes
  • New headlines/copy
  • Button color, size, placement
  • Form field optimization
  • Image variations

Let data guide evolution of pages over time. Continuously refine through controlled experiments.

Following this structured CRO audit approach, you can boost conversions through informed optimizations rooted in research and analytics. Avoid "gut feel" changes and instead let data illuminate the path forward.

CRO Tools to Enhance Your Audits

A variety of powerful tools can take your CRO audits to the next level. Recommended options include:

Heatmap and Session Replay Tools

  • Hotjar: Generates heatmaps showing where users click and scroll on your site. Also provides recordings of user sessions.

  • CrazyEgg: Heatmaps visualizing clicks, scrolling, and cursor movements. Overlay heatmaps to compare changes.

  • FullStory: Session replays and heatmaps. Lets you watch user recordings and analyze trends.

A/B and Multivariate Testing Tools

  • Optimizely: Full-featured testing platform. Handles everything from test design to analysis.

  • VWO: Provides A/B and multivariate testing with optimization recommendations.

  • Google Optimize: Free A/B testing tool integrated with Google Analytics. More limited features.

Survey Tools

  • Typeform: Build engaging online surveys with built-in analytics.

  • SurveyMonkey: Popular survey tool. Customizable surveys with skip logic and branching.

  • UsabilityHub: Get user feedback on designs through research surveys.

Analytics Platforms

  • Google Analytics: The standard for website analytics. Customizable reports, dashboards and tools for deep analysis.

  • Heap: Tracks user actions automatically. Retroactively analyze data with flexible segmentation.

  • Mixpanel: Advanced analytics focused on tracking user actions over time. Cohort analysis features.

The right tools provide immense insights to enhance your audit analysis and optimization efforts. Allocate budget to acquire capabilities that fill your needs.

Creating an Optimization-Focused Culture

While the tactical audit process is crucial, you should also build a culture focused on continuous optimization. Elements that help create this mindset include:

  • Dedicate cross-functional resources: Involve team members in audits and testing with clear ownership.

  • Provide optimization training: Ensure staff have needed skills and are aligned on goals.

  • Communicate wins and results: Share optimization success stories to motivate teams.

  • Incentivize innovation: Recognize employees who help lift key metrics through testing.

  • Emphasize accountability: Set performance standards tied to optimization KPIs.

  • Celebrate small gains: Even marginal improvements validate you’re on the right track.

With the right people, focus and enthusiasm behind it, your CRO program can truly transform your website's performance over time.

Getting Executive Buy-In for CRO

For many, getting executive signoff and budget for CRO initiatives can be challenging. Here are tips that can help:

  • Connect efforts to revenue: Show how conversion lifts impact sales and revenue directly. Speak their language.

  • Leverage quick wins: Point to early optimization wins as proof of concept. Build from there.

  • Start small: Propose a limited pilot program focusing on high-potential areas first.

  • Highlight competitive advantage: Demonstrate how CRO gives an edge over rivals.

  • Be persistent: Continue making your case over multiple discussions if needed.

With an ROI-focused approach, you can get leadership on board to fuel conversion optimization success.

Maintaining Momentum for Long-Term Results

The work doesn't end once the initial audit is complete. CRO is an ongoing process requiring maintenance for sustained results. Strategies to maintain momentum include:

  • Set quarterly or annual optimization targets to work toward.

  • Designate analytics review and testing days on team schedules.

  • Automate reporting to always have a pulse on performance.

  • Make small, continuous site enhancements part of regular routines.

  • Recognize and reward team members who drive optimizations forward.

  • Review successes and failures regularly and adjust strategies.

  • Share optimization insights cross-functionally so learnings spread.

With long-term commitment to honing your conversion rates through rigorous audits and testing, your site's true potential can be unlocked.

Start Uncovering Your Site's Untapped Potential Today

Now you have a proven framework to execute conversion rate optimization audits and transform your website into a customer-converting machine. By consistently reviewing analytics, surveying users, testing changes and monitoring performance, you can build on gains over time.

Don't leave money on the table due to site issues you haven't identified. Follow the steps outlined here to diagnose problems, find solutions and validate improvements through CRO. With conversion optimization best practices in place, you will reap the rewards of higher conversions and accelerated business growth.

The time is now to start tapping into your website's full potential. With the right focus, tools and commitment to continuous optimization, you will be amazed by the results.

Increase your service-based marketing by using a website.

Schedule a call with one of our website specialists and take the first step in optimizing your website. We’ll discuss your company goals, current website issues, technology, and marketing strategies. Together we'll determine the best way to help you achieve success.